Saturday, July 24, 2021

Hoping My Deer Killer Reputation Is and Remains History

 


When you tell someone that you hit and killed a deer, you will get several different reactions but almost always someone will tell you about their own incidents or near-incidents with deer. Every driver who lives anywhere where deer are occasional road traversers will have seen deer on, next to or crossing a road. It is also highly likely that these drivers will have seen the carnage left on deer and cars alike from the frequent interactions between members of the herd and varied vehicles. These “let me tell you what happened to me” stories about deer encounters of the frightening kind are modern variants of the “fisherman’s tale” along with their one-upmanship enhancements. It is a strange and perverse form of accomplishment for drivers, akin to the “one that got away” stories except that it takes the “didn’t get away” fatal plotline.

My story isn’t solely about one particular ‘car and deer’ collision. No, I have a sequence of encounters which earned me the appellation of “The Deer Killer” at work. This title resulted from commenting to some colleagues at lunch that I had had a near-miss with a deer when leaving from our work location one day. On that occasion, the interaction between my car and the deer was of the most minimal nature. Upon seeing the deer bound out of the foliage and into the road ahead of me, I slammed on the brakes and the car bumper just clipped a back hoof as the deer passed with no meaningful harm done to either. Now this is not an especially dramatic or noteworthy deer story; but it did bring up the afore-mentioned one-upmanship competition.

The lunch group heard about a range of story lines dealing with different contestants’ various offerings of their harrowing confrontations betwixt car and deer. After we had heard the stories about:

·         A deer jumping from the roadside right in-front of the car

·         A deer standing in the road around a curve

·         A deer bolting from behind bushes in people’s yards

·         A herd of deer running onto the road and hitting one or even two

Most of the stories were some version of these themes. They may have happened at night, in the morning or during the day. Stories took place in suburban neighbors, around farm fields, in wooded areas (like around the building I worked at), or on heavily traveled highways. There were stories of the does and the many pronged bucks woven into the mix. The vehicles spanned the gamut of new to old,  of large and small, and truck to family auto. The intensity of impact and its resulting damage also covered a wide spectrum of outcomes, both for deer and vehicle. After hearing each of the others’ adventures with our indigenous fauna of the bumper, I though I may have the story that ‘one ups’.

At an opportune moment of silence, a rare incident indeed at the lunch table, I calmly asked: “Who has hit the same deer twice?”  One of the quicker skeptics asked with an incredulous tone: “And how do you know it was the same deer on those two occasions?”  Everyone took on the same expression of doubt. “On no,” I said, “I did not mean on two separate occasions, I meant twice on the same one.” I went on to explain.

I was driving from graduate school to my future wife’s house to fetch her to a party that the graduate students were having during the holidays. Most of the route was through state forests or undeveloped land. It was a late fall evening and dark enough to require headlights. There was next to no traffic on the road, so I was making a good run in the rather dated Volkswagen I drove at that time. The first thing I saw was a rather large brownish form immediately in front of the car’s windshield descend from the right side of the road. I hit it dead on. I slammed on the brakes as fast as my brain could react.

This is where the event gets unique. The deer hit the hood and was driven straight forward and a little up in the air, just enough that it landed on its legs just in time for my car to hit it dead on again. I can’t say which hit killed the deer. But when the deer and the car came to a stop, it lay in front of the car and did not move. The visual memory of the collision is quite vivid. I got out of the car to see how much damage had been done, to see the state of the deer, and to determine if I was going to be able to drive the car.

Fortunately, for me given the circumstance, I was able to bend the right front fender up and away from the wheel thus allowing me to be able to drive; albeit with only one headlight intact. I pulled the deer off the road and then my car. Not to long after the accident, a passing truck stopped. The driver asked if I was alright, and I indicated that I was fine. He then asked me what I planned to do with the deer. I was a little taken aback and said that I was just going to report the incident (it was required by law to report hitting a deer and its location). The man asked if he could take it, and I said that was fine with me. He then invited me to come to his house when I was able to have some of the deer. I helped him load the deer in the back of his truck and thanked him for stopping to help.

That story seemed to be the winner, but it wasn’t for that story that I earned the dubious title of “Deer Killer”. There were some additional deer-involved incidents that occurred over time. These occurrences would also get related to my coworkers from time to time. Remember the one at the start of this sage, the deer running out of the woods at work. Well, there was also one where a deer jumped out onto the road (again from the right) during a drive into work where I hit the hindquarters of the dear. The deer kept running after it recovered from skidding over the road. I was hurt enough to prevent it from running but did not seem to be running normally. Then there were at least two times when I was driving home from work on one night and volleyball on another where I saw the deer standing by the side of the road in someone’s yard. It was only when I got close that each deer bolted right out into my car. One died, the other I don’t know what happened after it hobbled off.

There have been a couple of near misses. Somewhere along the line, it was suggested that I had developed the reputation in the deer community for being “The Deer Killer”; and any deer that wanted to commit suicide would come looking for me. I decide to write up this narrative when returning from a night of summer evening volleyball, I passed three separate locations where there was a deer just off the road that looked up as I approached and passed. Fortunately, none of these apparently knew my reputation or where in a death-wish state of mind.

I am hoping that I won’t be able to add any future ‘tails’ to my story.


Wednesday, July 21, 2021

School Choice in the Age of COVID: The Mask Issue

 


With the recent recommendation(s) for mask wearing in US schools for the 2021 Fall openings the arguments, fights, debates, and political / partisan divides over this particular issue could help provide a reasonable path forward for competently addressing these disputed among different groups. This is particularly true for states that have passed legislation or had official mandates issued to prevent school districts from ‘requiring’ mask wearing in a public school. Now from a public policy perspective there is never going to be a single public policy agreed to and an accepted resolution in any state. In a large population it is just illogical to expect there is going to be a sound and reasoned policy accepted by public who cannot agree on anything.

However, this irreconcilable difference in positions may actually offer what would seem to be the obvious solution. Why need there be a ‘single’ school solution that must be imposed upon one side or the other? After all, there are other options and solutions that might not only be agreeable to all parties but which provides additional benefits to the schools, the states and the nation. Wouldn’t it serve the public’s interest much better if rather than spend the time, energy and resources fighting over who’s rights and freedoms, and who’s political alignment is being supported to have a solution which satisfies the positions taken by each individual family and the schools and state/local leadership? If not, why is it essential that the interests of some must be sacrificed at the expense of others?

As to the solution I would think it would be obvious to politicians or school administrators. Implement a two-choice voluntary system. Let individual families choose whether their students attend a class where every student wears a mask, or they can choose to attend their class with students who do not wear masks. This selection would be applied across all aspects of the school. This would require that the schools plan and organize the execution of the school programs and class around this separation scheme. Who doesn’t get what they want if you just operate along a principle of let each family choose their own level of risks.

Another advantage of this dual-track approach would be that it could even accommodate a Vaccinated and Unvaccinated dimension related to the families’ adults. Of course, the Vaccinated vs Not Vaccinated dimension may almost perfectly align or overlap with the mask versus no-mask dimension.

From a public health policy perspective, this voluntary choice policy would enable the healthcare entities to gather data on the efficacy of the two choices. Since each group would have made their choice based on the same information and recommendations that have been made available by the experts there is no reason that the schools or government should be held accountable for those choices and any consequential outcomes. It’s a perfect solution. Everyone gets what they want and any consequences are within the scope of their choice.